Palm Beach County Letter to Justify
Recount
Wednesday, November 15, 2000; 3:29 PM
Text of letter sent
Wednesday by Palm Beach County elections officials to Secretary of State Katherine
Harris in relation to Democratic Party lawsuit:
Dear Secretary Harris:
This letter is in response to your request for a written statement of the facts
and circumstances which would necessitate a change to be made in the >final
certification of the statewide vote based on the results of Palm Beach County's
manual recount of all the ballots cast in Palm Beach County for the offices
of President and Vice President.
The Palm Beach county Canvassing Board has conducted a machine recount of the
ballots and a limited manual recount of 1 percent of the total votes cast in
accordance with Section 102.166(4)(d), Florida Statutes. The limited manual
recount produced different results than the machine recount. The machine recorded
approximately 10,000 undervotes. As stated in the Canvassing Board's Petition
For Extraordinary Writ, it elected to conduct a manual recount '(b)ecause the
results could affect the outcome of the election.'
See. 102.166(5), Fla. Stat.
On Sunday, November 12, 2000, the Canvassing Board voted to conduct a manual
recount of all the ballots cast in Palm Beach County for the offices of President
and Vice President pursuant to the authority granted to it under Section 102.166(5)(c),
Florida Statutes. As you are aware, the Canvassing Board also voted to seek
advisory opinions from the Division of Elections and the Attorney General regarding
the proper interpretation of Section 102.166(5), Florida Statutes. The opinions
were conflicting; accordingly, the >Canvassing Board is currently seeking an
adjudication by the Florida Supreme Court to resolve the conflicting opinions
on the question of whether the Canvassing Board may, under the above-referenced
circumstances, conduct a manual recount of the votes cast for President and
Vice President. The Canvassing Board has voted to suspend its manual recount
pending the resolution of this issue and other issues by the Florida Supreme
Court.
A manual recount of four precincts, which accounts for approximately one percent
of the total votes cast in Palm Beach County, resulted in a difference in the
vote totals. The 4,695 ballots manually recounted in four precincts resulted
in a total gain of 33 votes for Vice President Al Gore and 14 votes for Governor
George W. Bush, which is a net gain of 19 votes for Vice President Al Gore.
Clearly, the results of the manual recount could affect the outcome of this
very close presidential election if the manual recounts in the other precincts
also vary in this degree from the machine counts.
Sincerely,
The Honorable Charles Burton
County Court Judge, l5th Judicial Circuit
Chairperson, Palm Beach County Canvassing Board